Keyword: French Revolution

Answers to Sean Hannity, No. 9 Email Print

Mr. Hannity: "Monarchism, National Socialism, fascism, communism--all these forms of authoritarianism are illegitimate and inherently unjust." (pp. 10-11)

My response: I agree that National Socialism (Nazism) and communism are not legitimate forms of government because of their innate injustice. In different ways, both ideologies degrade the humanity of a people--Nazism through the elevation of society to godlike status, communism through the reduction of persons to mere cogs in the machinery of state. By eliminating socially "inferior" citizens, including Jews, Catholics, the mentally ill, and the handicapped, the racist and eugenicist Nazis worked to create a "master race" hoping to restore Germany's past glory. Communism is a collectivist system of government in which the state controls and regulates all the details of the ordinary lives of its citizens. While attempting to ensure the material security of all the citizens, it strips the individual person of his freedom--to worship God as he chooses, to purchase goods or property, to raise a family without interference, to determine his job, hours, or wage, to freely assemble with other citizens, to obtain a fair trial, or to criticize government policy.

Wait... There's more! (783 words in story)

"Let them eat cake" Bushie Style Email Print

Ardent Bushies detest any allusion of hated France.  They are the stalwart coiners of the term "freedom fries" while Air Force One served "freedom toast".  All the same, the recent FEMA contretemps involving Michael Brown brings one historical allusion to France prior to the days of the French Revolution into crystal clear focus.

Marie Antoinette became infamous by revealing herself as a cold and heartless French aristocrat with one frequently quoted comment that has reverberated through the pages of history.  When reminded that there were starving peasants in the streets of Paris she was alleged to have chillingly replied, "Let them eat cake."

While scholars and analysts attribute the cake comment to French philosopher and humanitarian Jean Jacques Rousseau seeking to make a completely different point, it has been regularly repeated to represent the quintessence of callous neglect and to buttress a fundamental reality. There is an underlying reality that people revolt when pushed too far, and starvation falls into this distinct category. Regrettably this same kind of crass materialism was revealed recently in the conduct of FEMA Director Michael Brown when he was informed of the urgency of the situation in Louisiana and Mississippi in the wake of a devastating hurricane.  

While many citizens of ravaged New Orleans stood at death's door Brown expressed concern about his sartorial style and how important it was to look good on national television.  The unfolding tragedy was a tasteless example of spoon-feeding vanity from a bureaucrat with an ultimate sinecure received from loyally supporting George Bush.  

Wait... There's more! (5 comments, 778 words in story)